1440 lawrence avenue west toronto

Toronto tenants and police stand off for hours following 'unfair' eviction

Tenants from two buildings in Toronto occupied their property manager's office overnight on Thursday to fight the "unfair" eviction of a senior tenant, who was reportedly evicted from her home despite her efforts to resolve her rent arrears. 

Multiple tenants from 1440-1442 Lawrence Ave. W., located near Keele Street, rallied against landlord Barney River following the eviction of their neighbour, who was allegedly "not notified of her eviction." 

According to a motion filed by the York South-Weston Tenant Union (YSW) to the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB), the tenant, Carmen Codnel, was evicted from her home on December 14 when the sheriff changed the locks on her unit after she left to pay the landlord the arrears owed. 

The union says that Codnel owed her landlord less than a month's rent — specifically, $536 — noting that "she is able to" and has "tried to" resolve her rent arrears. 

The application claims that Codnel did not know she was being evicted, as no mail is currently being delivered to her and other tenants due to the "gravity of disrepair and bed bug infestations in the building." 

A letter, posted by the building's local supervisory team in June 2023, instructs tenants to etrieve their mail from a Canada Post facility located roughly three kilometers from the buildings. 

The union alleges that since no mail is being delivered, Codnel did not receive a notice of hearing from the LTB, and therefore could not participate in her eviction hearing.

"She did not receive the eviction order made against her, and she did not receive the sheriff's notice to vacate. Had Ms. Codnel had the opportunity to attend her hearing or received notice of her eviction, she would have resolved her arrears," the union wrote. 

While the union has filed a motion with the LTB requesting an interim order for Codnel to get her union back, tenants say that Toronto police officers are still "threatening arrests" and "won't wait" for a resolution by the board. 

In response, tenants have been occupying the office of the buildings' property management for almost a full day now, challenging Codnel's eviction and refusing to leave until she is given her keys back. 

Several videos and photos posted by the union show a heavy police presence at the buildings as tenants continued to occupy the office. 

Multiple tenants stressed Codnel's precarious situation as a senior, racialized woman, and claimed that following her eviction, she was "not even allowed to get her diabetes medication." 

Over the next few hours, more neighbours and tenants joined the group to defend "Codnel's right to stay in her home." 

At approximately 3 a.m. Friday, the union revealed that police officers had left, while tenants continued their sit-in through the night "until the landlord fulfills their promise" to grant Codnel access back to her home.

Lead photo by

Livmore High Park Tenants


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in Real Estate

Here's why Ontario's largest mansion has sat abandoned for almost two decades

Buyers are still offering way under asking price for homes in most parts of Toronto area

Stylish $5 million Ontario home feels more like a luxury hotel than a house

Gorgeous Toronto condo on sale for $4.2 million is actually inside of an old mansion

The site of an approved Toronto condo project is for sale at $22.5 million

Huge 6-tower condo complex to replace popular Toronto flea market

Sleek $1.7 million Toronto home is steps away from one of the world's coolest streets

Huge Toronto neighbourhood will put almost 9,000 homes next to TTC and GO station