A pair of legendary discontinued Tim Hortons items returned to the iconic coffee and donut chain this week to celebrate National Donut Day on June 2, but one of them is generating buzz for all the wrong reasons.

The walnut crunch and cherry stick donuts are back on Tim Hortons' menu for a limited time, and based on social media reaction, it appears the masses were incredibly excited to get their hands on these retro flavours.

However, several purchasers of the walnut crunch donut have taken to the internet to comment on the snack's unappetizing visual similarity to a big ole' log of crap.

This looks like what I pick up after my dog, sorry pic.twitter.com/RueGfSluYX

— Dan Seljak (@anotherglassbox) June 1, 2023

Whether it's photos of the item itself or its representation on menus, many have acknowledged the walnut crunch donut looks more like food headed on the way out than on the way in.

"I seen a walnut crunch in the toliet this morning" NAHHH 😭😭💀💀 pic.twitter.com/gDw0I4oWz6

— FIX IT FELIX (@INSANE_JUNKRAT) June 2, 2023

That being said, those who are able to get over the baked good's amorphous, brown, and questionably-textured appearance report that the walnut crunch is actually pretty tasty — a point I am willing to corroborate from my personal experience eating one yesterday.

So after hearing about these yesterday, I had to stop in on the way to work this morning to pick some up. Not gonna lie, they are not the most appetizing looking but they sure taste good.#WalnutCrunch pic.twitter.com/POYuQkxG8Y

— Willy (@WillyGrant) June 1, 2023

Others disagree with this judgement, and have hurled all sorts of insults at the brand for a failed resurrection of an old favourite.

Much like the cat in Pet Semetary, sometimes things come back ~wrong.~

Tim Hortons did some foul resurrection magic with the walnut crunch. pic.twitter.com/ByC4Q4czUg

— Kristen Jeanveau (@kristenjeanveau) June 1, 2023

Another Timmies customer called the donut an "abomination," and later followed up in a second tweet that customers should "Keep your expectations low!"

How dare Tim Horton’s call this abomination a walnut crunch pic.twitter.com/058sDWUEoD

— Chris Boutet (@chrisboutet) May 31, 2023

The walnut crunch and cherry stick donuts had been unavailable for at least the last decade before the much-hyped return this month.

But even back in the early 2010s, when they last appeared at Tims, the walnut crunch was noted for its resemblance to a freshly-laid dump.

Why does the walnut crunch from Tim Hortons look like a log of frosted poop ?

— VICKY VU (@vuvicky) August 11, 2012

You can find the walnut crunch at Timmies locations across Canada and at participating Tims restaurants in Quebec, while the cherry stick is offered at all Tims in Quebec and participating restaurants elsewhere in the country.

It is easily distinguished from a real turd by its presence on a Tim Hortons baked goods rack, rather than a sidewalk or toilet bowl.