toronto tenant scam

Toronto police arrest tenant couple who scammed landlords for 10 years

A couple from Toronto has been arrested following a fraud investigation into an elaborate tenant scam police believe to have spanned a period of 10 years.

Gary Bachelor, 42, and Mandy Chapple, 45, are both facing multiple charges after being arrested by police on Feb. 24. 

Police allege that Bachelor and Chapple moved into eight different properties under rental agreements since 2010, and each time they moved in, according to police, they provided first and last month's rent but then immediately stopped paying rent and utilities as required by the rental agreement. 

"Property owners were forced to take matters to the Landlord Tenant Tribunal for early eviction," reads a news release from police. "The man and woman would then provide a number of fictitious excuses including loss of employment in order to prolong the eviction."

This, despite the fact that both Bachelor and Chapple were employed and have been with the same employer for more than a decade.

According to police, once the eviction process was complete, the couple would still owe payments to property owners but would continue to seek out other rental properties nonetheless — allegedly repeating the same pattern again and again.

As a result, both individuals are now facing seven counts of fraud over $5,000 and two counts of false pretence. 

They're both scheduled to appear in court virtually on April 7 at Toronto East Court, and anyone with information is asked to contact police or Crime Stoppers

Lead photo by

Ben Roffelsen Photography


Latest Videos



Latest Videos


Join the conversation Load comments

Latest in City

Tunnelling is now complete for Toronto's next huge transit project

People spotting Toronto's fancy Roombas for cutting grass in parks are enthralled

Ontario just got hit with an earthquake and officials blame this mine

TTC workers are gearing up to go on strike and here's what you need to know

Here are the highest and lowest paying gig jobs at the City of Toronto right now

Yonge-Dundas Square renaming to Sankofa Square is about to become more official

A 7-kilometre stretch of the TTC subway will be closed for this entire weekend

Years of construction on major Toronto street set to extend even longer with new project