Toronto's Forgotten Landmarks: Christ Church - St. James

Christ Church - St. JamesA block north of College and Shaw street, amidst a sleepy neighbourhood appointed with ample trees and schools sprawling northward, sits the ruins of Christ Church - St. James. Now nothing more than the hollowed husk and memory of an old church, it possesses a story so surprising and full of intrigue that it's only matched in tale by the mystery of its ghost like image.

Christ Church - St. JamesIt was just over four years ago that my relationship with this building began. My friend Jeff Chapman was keen to give me directions to the place after I had seen it on his website.

Leaving early in the morning, I spent quite some time in the place which is perhaps best described as an oblong pit with the remains of adjacent walls as well as a charred remaining northern wall that gives it the semblance of once having been a church.

My most important discovery that day came upon climbing over the fence on my way out, and being greeted by the ruin's neighbour. He came over to help me with my tripod, and asked if I was there taking photos, and then if I was a student at UofT.

"Well, if that's the case, I've got quite a story for you", he said, upon my answering to the affirmative. Without leaving out too much detail, I will briefly describe the tale I heard on that auspicious day - I will admit that much of it may be regarded as hearsay, but the little probing I was able to carry out subsequently confirms many of the elements, and pulls together the story of the murder, the fire and the ruins of Christ Church - St. James.

A professor at the University of Toronto's famous Banting and Best institute (known for its groundbreaking diabetes research) also happened to be the treasurer for a small church in the western Annex. One day, upon arrival at work at the Medical Science department, co-workers found his offices stripped of recent breakthrough research, and the professor himself and his lab partner missing.

The latter was subsequently discovered in one of the facility's morgue drawers, and before this particular series of strange events was seen through, another tragedy struck the city: a series of (apparent) arson fires in a neighbourhood not far from the school.

One of these scorched the building at hand, number 460 Shaw Street, a small church which moved to its then current location in the 1950s. After quelling the fires, the congregation needed to complete the demolition, yet upon looking into the church funds, they too were discovered missing.

Surprisingly, the police were never able to solve any of these suspicious crimes, but years later, the body of the professor was found rotting in a car which had careened off of a road near the Scarborough Bluffs; the gentleman who told me this story added an interesting caveat, in that he himself worked near the scene of this final tragedy, and made the claim that it was impossible for the incident to have occurred 'naturally', he driving the same route on a daily basis for quite some years.

One cannot fabricate stories such as these; the reality of the human animal in the city, his tales and actions, are often stranger than fiction. This story sparked a somewhat dark enthusiasm in me to research it farther, however, my plans were truncated very quickly at UofT, where absolutely no one was willing to speak on the matter - over a decade after the events.

After so many years of dormancy, the site is finally slated for revision (as condos, no less), and I therefore urge you to go and visit this place, the dark stage to an urban tragedy - to bear witness to this entropic, black spot on our city's past.

Christ Church - St. James

Here's a slideshow of some snaps I've taken over the years at this haunting place:

Reader Reviews and Comments

Submit a Review or Comment

Great article and photos! I remember when it burned but I had never heard that story before. Always enjoy hearing about the history of the buildings, places and people of Toronto.

Posted by: O. Terry [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 16, 2008 11:12 AM

Great shots!
A couple small details he was not a professor, both were just service workers at Medical Science Building.
And there was no car crash, only a small box of bones were recovered everything else scavenged by animals.
I was working there the day of the incident.

Posted by: le ghost at September 16, 2008 11:16 AM

Le Ghost - thank you for the correction! As I said, I was merely basing it on what I've heard (from the neighbour and a few others) - I will change the info on uer.ca as well to reflect what you said - very exciting, thanks!

Jonathan.

Posted by: Jonathan Castellino at September 16, 2008 11:21 AM

The sign for condo development has been up for years. Are they finally going ahead with it?

I explored the church two years ago on a sunny day and got some great shots. It was months later that I learned its history and discovered is one of those places that a lot of people know about and visit. A friend who lived in the neighbourhood used to walk by daily and was curious. He decided that if he was going in, he was taking an accomplice. This was before I knew that "urban exploration" existed.

Posted by: AT [TypeKey Profile Page] at September 16, 2008 11:36 AM

AT - heh, ya, I know they have had that sign/ones like it over the years; a fairly credible source has informed me that they actually ARE going to move on it now-

Thanks for the comments!

Jonathan.

Posted by: Jonathan Castellino at September 16, 2008 11:47 AM

I've been down there a few times. Great to learn more from your stories, Jonathan. I joined some younger folks in watching a horror film down there on Devil's Night last year, which makes it all the creepier now.

Posted by: Jerrold at September 16, 2008 11:50 AM

great story, first time i hear the whole story, the dark pictures really tell a story by themselves

Posted by: tomms at September 16, 2008 2:25 PM

The best part about the condo development effort was the company with an "@aol.com" email address on it's sign. How legitimate does that seem?

Posted by: ian at September 16, 2008 3:09 PM

This used to be one of my favourite spots in the city to simply visit, if nothing else. I'm sure you can empathize, Jonathan. Great write-up. It's one of Toronto's most mysterious secrets.
I did a project in my third year at ocad to create a counter monument and I chose this site. My idea was to cast the wall along Shaw street (the interior side) and create a concrete replicate, capturing every detail of burnt wood and surface imperfections. Ground zero would be transformed into a park with the monument along the west end of the pit and two concrete pews facing it.

Posted by: Nick at September 16, 2008 9:25 PM

Nick,
that sounds really neat - do you have any pictures of the project? About a year ago I had this dream where CCSJ was a park - and when I woke I did a rough sketch of it as such (cleaned up, walls left etc, but with grass/swing sets et al), and the more I think about, the better it sounds...hah, I guess the idea of nonprofitable land won't sound to good to the developers. They have sketches of what the new condos are going to look like up on billboards on the property now; they start at well over $700K !

Jonathan.

Posted by: Jonathan Castellino at September 17, 2008 5:07 PM

I first went to this church when I was 12 years old with my friends and have been hanging out there ever since. I live across the lane and I thought it was the coolest place ever when me and my friends first found it. It was cool and I remember me and my friends last spring decided to make it cool in there by bringing chairs left behind the mod club into the church to make it a cooler place to hang out in. Later before the summer we discovered a group of twelve year olds hanging out in the church. Although they did draw penises all over the place it was a strange reminder of my past. Things changed when I got mugged there in July, I never went back until late august and was pretty sad that an other fire had recently occured leaving the whole upper floor burnt. I guess there was an other fire recently.. that Sucks

Posted by: Sasha at September 29, 2008 11:27 PM

The first time I went in there was sometime in July and I remember smelling burnt wood. I guess the second fire was set not long before, or on the very same day I went. I sucked cause I wanted to go up the stairs on the upper floor after seeing some pictures. The upper floor was still stable enough to support me, but there was no way I would go on the stairs in the condition it was in.

Posted by: spirit at October 9, 2008 9:21 PM

Post a comment

Remember Me?

Email This Entry

Email 'Toronto's Forgotten Landmarks: Christ Church - St. James' to: Message (optional):
Your email address:

Please type the verification code displayed in the image:

By forwarding this entry to a friend, we do not opt you or your friend into
receiving any additional mailings from blogTO. We hate spam too.
Disclaimer: Comments and blog entries represent the viewpoints of the individual and no one else.