Sunday Book review: "Spent"

20070128_Spent.jpg

"Spent" by Joe Matt is a little book with big problems. It's about a self-loathing, chronic- masturbating, penny-pinching comic book artist who is writing a book about a self-loathing, chronic-masturbating, penny-pinching, comic book artist. And it does a pretty good job of encapsulating everything that is wrong with underground comics.

I kept waiting for a story - any story - to emerge. None ever did. The whole book consists of the main character, Joe Matt, dubbing porn, complaining and urinating in a jar. If I wanted to spend time with someone like that, I wouldn't read this book. I'd visit my grandfather. At least he has some funny stories.

The bulk of the book takes place in mid-nineties Toronto, during the years that Joe Matt was living illegally here. But, really, it could take place anywhere. The settings are as irrelevant as the non-existent story. The characters are the focal point but Matt doesn't do anything with them that we haven't seen Robert Crumb or Harvey Pekar do much better.

Even the art is weak, using the same two panels across and four panels down on every single page. This would be fine if "Spent" had something else to fall back on. It doesn't.

The back of the book refers to Matt as a "comedic genius" and maybe he is. But I'm not. Perhaps that explains why I didn't laugh once or even crack a smile. Except for when it was finally over. I was pretty happy then.

Reader Reviews and Comments

Submit a Review or Comment

Dont' be so hard with him!! His work his great, or at least uncommun, and in the middle of all this shit production, it's already a good point for him. I think also that if you aren't yoursefl a bit Joe Matt, you can not understand how brillant it is and how hard is the live of a complaining chronical unsatisfied masturbator!!

Posted by: thierry at April 26, 2007 5:37 AM

Dude,

The story is just the story. There is no story. It's all set-up and subtext and commentary.

I think that you need to read it again - preferrably the finished hard covered edition of the book - and while you're reading it quit being so hard on yourself. See past what you're seeing on the page.

Matt's genius is in his humour and the contruction of his stories.

Posted by: Joe Deadly at July 6, 2007 10:24 AM

I have no problems with your review, until I noted this ignorant sentence:

"...art is weak... using the same two panels across and four panels down on every single page"

Sorry to break it to you, but it is the best cartoonists that know not to fuck around with panel layouts: Pulitzer winning Maus, Jason, Chester Brown's critically acclaims Louis Reil, are prime examples. Even Chris Ware exploits the standardization of panels from time to time.

If you want flashy, wacky panel variation go read a superhero comic or something. At least that'll capture your attention more than reading the sordid details about Matt's personal life.

Posted by: Scottgalle at December 27, 2007 12:46 PM

Post a comment

Remember Me?

Email This Entry

Email 'Sunday Book review: "Spent"' to: Message (optional):
Your email address:

Please type the verification code displayed in the image:

By forwarding this entry to a friend, we do not opt you or your friend into
receiving any additional mailings from blogTO. We hate spam too.
Disclaimer: Comments and blog entries represent the viewpoints of the individual and no one else.